5 Posts
4,441 followers
Derek Handley

Influencer

Astronaut in Waiting, Virgin Galactic / Resident Entrepreneur at The B Team

Three Reasons to Steal, Not Copy. Here's How and Why

 
Lacking inspiration today? Trying too hard to come up with unique ideas that the world has never seen? Here's an angle for you: 'steal' other people's and put them together in a way that you and only you can. I'm a true believer that nothing is really new in the world, it's just a constant rehash of old or existing ideas. What's new is how those old ideas are put together, mixed, mashed and clashed, and that is what makes things entirely new and special. Steve Jobs didn't invent the mouse, the graphical user interface, the digital music player, the phone - none of them. He just reinvented the way they were put together, and the contexts in which they were inserted into popular culture. To be clear - it's not plagiarism we're talking about; and it's not the stealing that gets you in jail or a reputation as a fraud - it's basically seeing things and saying, "I love that. And I'm going to use it. But I'm going to put it here instead, and I'm going to do it this way and not that."
Here is a classic clip of Steve Jobs speaking to this idea and of exposing yourself to the best things that humans have done across all spectrums of life, and bringing them into what you are doing in your particular discipline.
Jim Jarmusch is an indie filmmaker who puts it another way.
“Nothing is original. Steal from anywhere that resonates with inspiration or fuels your imagination. Devour old films, new films, music, books, paintings, photographs, poems, dreams, random conversations, architecture, bridges, street signs, trees, clouds, bodies of water, light and shadows. Select only things to steal from that speak directly to your soul. If you do this, your work (and theft) will be authentic. Authenticity is invaluable; originality is non-existent. And don’t bother concealing your thievery - celebrate it if you feel like it. In any case, always remember what Jean-Luc Godard said: “It’s not where you take things from - it’s where you take them to.”
In the clip Jobs also speaks to something I think we all underrate and never do anywhere near enough of in the everyday world: clashing extremely diverse professions, thoughts and backgrounds around a challenge, in order to create a truly diverse outcome. Far too often we revert to the same old 'go to' people who know about this and that, and are experts in this and that. But far too often they are dry, stale and have become a cog in their own machine - drowning in their 'expert-ness', they are hard pressed to think of the most obvious things. And often won't come up with the most non-obvious either.
Experts and specialists often know too much to open up to broad creative thinking that sometimes requires less knowledge of a problem rather than more. So, when you bring 'non-experts' into the fold and 'steal' from their totally unrelated thought processes or expertise - magic can happen. Great thinking often comes from the edge - the periphery of where the core activity is actual taking place.
Get out of your own industry, take a walk to the opposite side where you'd never be expected to be found and get inspired by ideas both contemporary and historical to inspire you to rethink your intuitive daily rhythm. Mix it up and you'll be surprised how fresh thinking just lands on you.
Be an artist for a day and follow Picasso's charge:

'Good artists copy. Great artists steal.'

Oh, and I don't really have a specific "Three Reasons". I just noticed all the LinkedIn Influencer articles have "Three Reasons" for this, or "The Five Things You Must" of that, so I thought why not borrow that and make it my own?
Photo: Tom Munnecke / Contributor / Getty Images
Clip: YouTube
Click below to follow me on Linkedin, or find me on Twitter @dgh
Paul Jeong

  • Mark Montgomery
    Mark Montgomery
    Chairman & CEO at Kyield
    Hope you have good lawyers--you are gonna need a bunch of em. Terrible presentation, wrong message. Poor leadership. Yes innovation is a mix of bringing together many pieces of puzzles--it is an art form, but theft isn't the right message at all. Property rights are the foundation upon which shoulders all entrepreneurs stand, and should be respected, unless you want the economy to fall apart beneath your lofty goals. I really don't like seeing this in public, especially on LI. You can't see the damage it does, but I do.
    5 hours ago
    16 Replies
    • Julia Qiu, Ph.D.
      Julia Qiu, Ph.D. 2nd
      International Trade
      This article sends a wrong message. We need to encourage originality, creativity, honesty and pushing human boundaries.
      57 minutes ago
    • David Bloch
      David Bloch
      Business Intelligence Practice Lead at Optimation
      Oh I see, you have an issue with reading comprehension - you don't actually enjoy reading what other people write, you just enjoy having a soap box to stand on. As you were, Mr Trillion Dollars.
      1 hour ago
    • Show More
  • Kalyn Wolfe
    Kalyn Wolfe
    Project Manager, iModules at University of West Florida
    Actually, if you're talented enough, you don't have to copy... or steal. You can just be you and watch all the pieces fall into place. I hate copycats and I hate people who can't provide their own original flair to anything. If you can't be yourself, then you're just another corporate shell.
    5 hours ago
    2 Replies
  • Ada Torres-Ramírez
    Ada Torres-Ramírez
    Sustainability & Environmental Management Consultant
    Einstein did it to Poincaré and Lorentz.
    5 hours ago
    8 Replies
  • Ken Ammon
    Ken Ammon
    Cybersecurity Executive
    I believe there is a big difference between innovating and stealing. Anyone who has suffered theft of their innovation knows what I'm talking about. I get the point...I just think the words send the wrong message.
    5 hours ago
    1 Reply
  • Jesse Gigandet
    Jesse Gigandet
    Art Director, Graphic Designer, Animator, Web Developer, Illustrator
    Although there is inspiration all around us, and everyone is influenced in some way or another by the things they've seen, "stealing" is NEVER encouraged nor condoned. By stealing, you're referring to taking something someone else created and calling it your own - sorry, but you are dead wrong from a moral perspective, and extremely dangerous from a legal and copyright perspective. Shame on you for encouraging such a practice... great artists do NOT steal.
    5 hours ago
    • Ross Armstrong
      Ross Armstrong
      Executive Advisor at Info-Tech Research Group
      If you have no qualms stealing from the greats, then you'll have no problem stealing from your friends, peers, colleagues, and coworkers. Just ask Tobias Frere-Jones how he feels about that. Or Steve Wozniak. Or Eduardo Saverin. Drawing inspiration is one thing. Full-on thievery is just contemptible.
      5 hours ago
      • Joe Micallef
        Joe Micallef
        Media Consultant/Writer at 3D Printer World
        Do your research. You are lazily repeating what other people have said, without knowing the true origins of the quote "'Good artists copy. Great artists steal." The origins of the quote began in 1892 with Davenport Adams who said, “That great poets imitate and improve, whereas small ones steal and spoil.” Over the years the quote has been bastardized by others, including Steve Jobs. Most people assume Picasso said "Good artists copy... etc..." just because Steve Jobs said so, but Picasso's quote has never been verified. In our cut-n-paste culture, many people live by the Steve Jobs quote since it makes stealing acceptable. For help give this a read: http://quoteinvestigator.com/2013/03/06/artists-steal/
        5 hours ago
        3 Replies
        • Jer'Maine Jones
          Jer'Maine Jones
          Software Engineer 1B at L-3 Communications Integrated Systems
          It's purely semantics. The quote isn't inherently wrong: where "copy" is literal, in that it's plagiarism; "steal" is "taking of something and owning it", which could both be plagiarizing OR, in this context placing it opposite of copy, the act of taking an idea and remixing it.
          31 minutes ago
        • Guillaume Danel
          Guillaume Danel 2nd
          Senior Consultant in the Technology Sector at Boyd & Moore Executive Search
          Like Abraham Lincoln said: "Don't believe everything you read on the Internet".
          1 hour ago
        • Show More
      • Victor Curran
        Victor Curran
        Account Executive at Precision Graphics
        When I was teaching graphic design, I used to tell my students that there's nothing wrong with stealing ideas. The only thing that's wrong is stealing bad ideas.
        5 hours ago
        2 Replies
        • Fredrik Kylander
          Fredrik Kylander
          Graphic+web designer
          Sadly all they (seem to) hear is "there's nothing wrong with stealing"... And, to be clear, stealing ideas is just as bad as stealing material things.
          32 minutes ago
        • Kirk Kenny
          Kirk Kenny
          Senior Designer at Betfair
          That said when I was at college I remember one male student tracing adverts straight out of magazines, the whole kit & kaboodle and passing them off as his own. He's still working in design and a lot higher up than I am.
          2 hours ago
      • Barnett Williams
        Barnett Williams
        Sales Associate, Account Management
        Read the book 'Borrowing Brilliance' by David Kord Murray. Same theory expanded. David explains through examples around Einstein, Larry Page and Sergey Brin of Google, George Lucas, Steve Jobs and more. “The secret to creativity is knowing how to hide your sources.” —Albert Einstein
        5 hours ago
        • Fernando De Los Reyes
          Fernando De Los Reyes
          CTOC Network Analyst at USSOUTHCOM
          Yes, there is nothing new under the sun. All you can do "add value" by incorporating your personal idiosyncrasies and there you have it.
          6 hours ago
          1 Reply
        • Alexander Maromaty
          Alexander Maromaty
          Principal Engineer at Rockwell Collins
          I don't comment on things very often but this caught my eye right away. I look at this after being in the computer software industry for over thirty five years. copying something that someone else created and let alone purporting that "stealing" something from someone is an acceptable practice in any kind of business is reprehensible. So what everyone is to expect is that the pirates of Silicon Valley are still stealing ideas and code from each other? And the little guy who got 50K for his operating system that created the basis for MS-DOS and the windows file system should be happy? Legalized stealing is what it is. I hate this kind of garbage because it is detrimental to the people that do the real work, the innovators who are coming up with new ideas. If they have no incentive because someone is going to copy their code or steal it - what gives them the incentive to work hard to innovate? The lawyers as usual are the only ones that benefit from crap like this. The person that put this article put here should be ashamed of themselves.
          2 hours ago
          1 Reply
          • Erik Solomonson
            Erik Solomonson
            Holistic Information Security at _____________
            You are quite right. Imagine if a "little person" advocated "stealing" for greatness? But a couple of billionaires duke it out and then one comes out on top and the rest of us are supposed to say "oooh! how inspirational the way our betters did something that would give the rest of us an electronic monitor around our ankle!" We may as well just bring back Sumtuary Laws where only the turtleneck wearing upper class is permitted to engage in copyright violation and non-conformity.
            2 hours ago
        • Nathan Coulombe
          Nathan Coulombe
          Solution Specialist
          Did you tell this to Apple's patent lawyers? I think they should hear it.
          2 hours ago
          • Allen Wade
            Allen Wade
            CIO, Co-Founder, Inventor, Bitsavr Incorporated.
            'Good artists copy. Great artists steal.' - Why is Apple suing Samsung again?
            1 hour ago
            1 Reply
            • Tiberiu Gherasim
              Tiberiu Gherasim 2nd
              Executive Search Consultant at East West Consulting (Japan)
              Because the person that wrote this article forgot to say, that Steve Jobs recipe is not only stealing the idea, it's also killing the person you steal from...
              1 hour ago
          • Timothy Miller
            Timothy Miller
            Visionary IT Leader, Business Relationship Manger
            Stealing is not only unethical, it shows a lack of innovation on the part of the thief. If you cannot improve on the idea, perhaps your only focus is making money. Wrong approach. The world is full of those types. Try doing something that benefits society when the product arrives. Let's pose it like this, would Warren Buffet steal an idea, then become one of the largest philanthropist of his time? No. He is an innovator. So the lesson, never stop looking to make the world a better place, and in that process, make yourself a better person. Who wants "he sure made a lot of money by stealing ideas, but died with it doing nothing of consequence" on their headstone? Choose wisely, your impact will either be positive for the following generations, or degenerative in nature. So, what do you want to be remembered for, self-centeredness, or someone who cared enough to spend their time making a positive difference. Maybe, just maybe, the innovator could use a hand to help build their idea. Ever think of that approach? That too doesn't require five reasons, it's just one. "I want to matter."
            5 hours ago
            2 Replies
            • Kyle Knocke
              Kyle Knocke
              I.T. Enterprise Equipment Supplier @ Genisys Corporation
              Its just having an idea, finding out everything about who is trying to implement it and how they are trying, and doing it better.
              3 hours ago
            • Kyle Knocke
              Kyle Knocke
              I.T. Enterprise Equipment Supplier @ Genisys Corporation
              No idea is original.. even if it appears that way to you, 1000 other people have already thought it and 2 or 3 are trying to implement it. Hate to break it to you.
              3 hours ago
          • John Black
            John Black
            Vice President - Consulting Services at Nielsen Marketing Analytics, Inc.
            If the term "repurpose" replaces "steal" in the video and quote it plays a lot better.
            5 hours ago
            • Linda Naiman
              Linda Naiman
              Corporate Alchemist, Creativity & Innovation expert, Coach, Educator, Speaker
              'Good artists copy. Great artists steal.' is a widely misunderstood quote, which taken at face value, gives people permission to steal. If you look closely at Picasso's work, you will see he did not steal, he took an idea and transformed it. As Jean-Luc Godard said: “It’s not where you take things from - it’s where you take them to.” This is an important distinction, and one that is lost on many so-called creatives. I personally have had my blog posts, articles, and artwork stolen by consultants, writers, universities, and companies. Not very creative.
              3 hours ago
              • Sanne Houwing
                Sanne Houwing
                Copywriter @ Oogst
                Your three reasons-pun made me giggle.
                5 hours ago
                4 Replies
                • Sanne Houwing
                  Sanne Houwing
                  Copywriter @ Oogst
                  Definitely Miss Right. Though I am more of a lefty. You see, I'm from Holland, so even our right is nowhere near the American left. It's also quite late here, so I'm calling it a night. Give your maternally outraged gorilla a big kiss from Amsterdam. You go play with your genomes now ;)
                  3 hours ago
                • Vladimir Svetlov
                  Vladimir Svetlov
                  Senior Research Scientist at NYU Langone Medical Center
                  He is not available. He is still waiting for Miss Right to come along and gather him in her arms. Or for maternally outraged gorilla. Where do you think you fit on this here spectrum? ;-)
                  4 hours ago
                • Show More
              • Sarah Elkins
                Sarah Elkins
                Public Affairs Specialist, Storyteller, Customer Service Maven, Professional Musician
                It's too bad a brilliant concept was lost in the middle of this post: ...clashing extremely diverse professions, thoughts and backgrounds around a challenge, in order to create a truly diverse outcome. Now THAT's brilliant.
                3 hours ago
                1 Reply
                • Glenda Claborne
                  Glenda Claborne
                  Librarian at The American University of Iraq, Sulaimani
                  Was just thinking about that as I scrolled through the mostly negative responses to the article. Someone started with a negative comment then everyone else followed suit in the same spirit. I do want to comment on the brilliant concept - on the 'truly diverse outcome' part. I see the creative process as starting with divergence of ideas but there should be convergence in the outcome, otherwise we cannot arrive at truly innovative outcomes that would benefit the common good.
                  12 minutes ago
              • Daniel Gullo
                Daniel Gullo 2nd
                Synergist at SolutionsIQ, Certified Scrum Trainer (CST), Certified Scrum Coach (CSC)
                P.S. Article stolen from Austin Kleon's NYT award winning book: "Steal Like An Artist"
                5 hours ago
                1 Reply
                • Kelvin Chu
                  Kelvin Chu
                  Lean Implementation Strategist / Project Coordinator at WorleyParsons
                  Spot on Daniel! Perhaps this "influencer" has merely imitated work such as Austin Kleon’s as opposed to transforming into something of his own.
                  6 minutes ago
              • Todd Chipman
                Todd Chipman
                Founder and CEO at Spreezio, Inc
                I completely disagree with this premise! I've innovated over-and-over in my career without having to steal or copy anyone. Innovation requires talent, imagination and hard work.... nothing more, nothing less!
                3 hours ago
                1 Reply
                • Connie Huffa
                  Connie Huffa
                  Fearless Product Development & Innovations Executive + 3D Knitting Magician
                  Exactly. This is also the same guy who said he'd 'rather be a pirate than join the navy.' That's like saying he'd rather set fires than fight them. I just see this as a misplaced trust in a role model who'd rather be feared for his temper and bullying, than making an honest success. This was not a nice person. What's this say to our next generation?
                  2 hours ago
              • Show More