Wednesday, October 2, 2013

“Piano Hero” Concept Video Makes Me Want To Try To Learn The Piano For The 500th Time


  • Comment
    20

    “Piano Hero” Concept Video Makes Me Want To Try To Learn The Piano For The 500th Time

    GREG KUMPARAK

    posted 3 hours ago
    20 Comments
    piano hero
    Take a piano. Strap a projector above it. Build a Guitar Hero-esque interface that shows upcoming notes, and project it down onto the Piano’s top surface and keys. What do you get?
    The piano instructor of the freakin’ future. Or, at least, a piano instructor that won’t yell at you and make you wish you decided to stick with soccer after all.
    Highlighted in a video by NewScientist this morning, the Projected Instrumented Augmentation System is a project built by a team out of Germany’s Ulm University. Combining the aforementioned projection setup with logic that detects what you’re playing, the system is able to illuminate mis-pressed keys, and can move the song’s notes along at your pace.
    Yeah, yeah. This might not teach you to actually play the piano — at least, not without lugging a big ol’ projector with you everywhere or memorizing everything you want to play. It certainly won’t teach you how to read sheet music. But it would help you get more comfortable poundin’ away at the old ivories,and help you learn to contort your hands into the many crazy shapes that piano playing requires. Plus, it probably feels pretty awesome to play along with.
    This certainly isn’t the first time we’ve seen piano playing gamified, with companies like Konami (withKeyboard Mania), Harmonix (with Rock Band 3) and to some extent Smule (with Magic Piano for iPad) having toyed with the concept in their own ways. But this is the first time I’ve seen it mashed up directlyonto the piano — and man, does that look rad.
    If you’ve got a MIDI keyboard and are looking for something sort of similar (albeit without the crazy projection setup), check out Synthesia.
    20 comments
    Zaki
    Zaki
    The "piano roll" format is a very typical way of displaying music in sequencers. It is very visual and very well suited for editing recorded music, but as I see it not as an alternative to sheet music. It is too difficult and ambiguous to read if there is a lot going on. Imaging playing a lot of chords as well as a bassline at the same time. I believe that this is more limited than the existing sheet music systems, although the learning curve might be less steep due to the direct visual mapping to the piano. Also it is not universally applicable for other instruments such as flute or guitar.
    It is really nice for beginners, though, to get some visual feedback as soon as they play a wrong note, but maybe their time is better spend learning to read actual sheet music - and maybe we should rather look into supplying the same visual feedback within the world of sheet music?
    Joshua Vantard
    Joshua Vantard from Facebook
    I have to agree. Such systems have potential but the current state of the piano world means it will be a while before this punches into any market share on good old sheet music.
    GuyVago
    GuyVago
    Playing an instrument is not just hitting the right notes at the right time.
    Students have to learn how to hold their hand, how to move it when scaling up/down.
    How to control the feel and volume.
    This is a tech approach for piano. 
    Funny but nothing more.
    haha
    joshua.v
    joshua.v
    @GuyVago I agree, but such advancements may make piano feel more accessible to new players. It will be a while before these automated notes punch into any meaningful sheet music market share. First, it needs to become affordable, then pianos have to change so these can be mounted. Even when this happens, it will simply make 'reading notes' easier and piano's about much more than that.
    Sam.Giovino
    Sam.Giovino
    I played Guitar Hero growing up and it really helped me learn how to play drum set better. I feel as if this could actually help you play piano in the same way. Guitar Hero helps learn the movements and rhythms of drums. Now yes, guitar is harder to learn, but drums are almost the same. I feel this could sharpen novice piano players, but can't make them the best players.
    Kévin Bouchard
    Kévin Bouchard from Facebook
    The problem with that is that you don't really learn to play, I am very good with synthesia and I have learn many song (some being advanced), but I am still not able to read music or to understand the basics of piano
    joshua.v
    joshua.v
    This isn't that new: http://www.synthesiagame.com/
    terinjokes
    terinjokes
    @joshua.v This is exactly what I thought the article was going to be about, I've definitely hooked up my midi keyboard and tried out that game several times.
    GregKumparak
    GregKumparak TechCrunch
    @joshua.v Oh yeah, I know. I've actually got a (admittedly dusty) keyboard sitting in the corner of my office for use with Synthesia. Before that, I probably shelled a good $200 bucks into getting owned by Keyboard Mania at a local arcade.
    As I mention in the post, it's not the first time we've seen piano gamified - just the first time I've seen it done in a way that brings the notes into the real world like this. Having the notes scroll around on a screen is neat, but having them scroll down 1:1, directly onto the keys themselves is totally different. 
    joshua.v
    joshua.v
    @GregKumparak @joshua.v  This is indeed cool. It would be a service to the technology community to pay credit where it is due and mention Synthesia rather than just these 3 you mentioned which aren't quite as useable. Put it into context. How expensive will this be compared to Synthesia? Will it work for all pianos? Your article could be researched better. It recycles the New Scientist article and it would be fantastic if we could see some more original research and reporting here. I and other of my friends who read Techcrunch feel the quality of articles are dropping. These are articles anyone of us could write ourselves. They seem to be hype stirrers rather than good, contextual, well researched reporting.

    Give me an article to write and I will show you what I mean.

    No comments:

    Post a Comment

    Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.